Sleep Training Method: Cry it Out
Before beginning any sleep training method, ensure you have consulted with your pediatrician to confirm it's appropriate for your baby's health and developmental stage. Additionally, always respond to your baby's needs for feeding throughout the process to ensure their well-being.
If you're a parent struggling with your baby's sleep, you've likely heard of the "cry it out" method. This sleep training technique, often surrounded by a fair bit of controversy, promises to help your baby sleep independently through the night. But what exactly does "cry it out" entail, and is it right for your family?
As a baby sleep specialist, I've seen firsthand how the cry it out method can transform sleep routines. However, I also understand the hesitation many parents feel when considering this approach. The idea of letting your baby cry can be daunting, and it's essential to have all the facts before making a decision.
With my own children, I ended up doing Cry It Out. I started with the Ferber method, but quickly noticed that my babies were getting more upset when I would come in and then leave again. Each time I came in, my kids expected that I would pick them up and rock them to sleep. When I didn’t do that, and I left the room, their crying would escalate even more. So, with both kids, I ended up eventually getting to Cry it out. It was hard but also worked quickly.
In this article, we'll dive deep into the cry it out method, exploring its principles, effectiveness, and controversies. Whether you're just curious or considering trying it yourself, this guide will provide you with a comprehensive understanding of cry it out and how it might fit into your family's sleep strategy.
What is the Cry It Out Method?
The cry it out method, often referred to as CIO, is a sleep training technique designed to teach babies how to self-soothe and fall asleep independently. Unlike more gradual methods, CIO involves allowing your baby to cry for a predetermined amount of time before offering comfort. The goal is to help your baby learn to fall asleep without relying on external aids, such as rocking, nursing, or holding.
The Basics of Cry It Out
The cry it out method is based on the idea that babies can learn to self-soothe if given the opportunity. Here's a simple breakdown of how it typically works:
Bedtime Routine: Establish a consistent and calming bedtime routine. This might include a bath, reading a book, and cuddling. The routine signals to your baby that it's time to sleep.
Put Baby to Bed Awake: After the routine, place your baby in their crib while they are still awake. This is crucial because it helps them learn to fall asleep in their bed rather than in your arms.
Leave the Room: Once your baby is in the crib, leave the room.
My Personal Experience
A week into sleep training my daughter, we decided to try the cry it out method. Initially, I was hesitant. The thought of letting her cry without immediately comforting her was heart-wrenching. But after months of sleepless nights, we were desperate for a solution.
The first night was the hardest. She cried for what felt like an eternity, but in reality, it was about 20 minutes. By the third night, her crying reduced significantly, and within a week, she was falling asleep on her own with minimal fuss. It was a game-changer for our family.
Why Some Parents Choose Cry It Out
Many parents choose the cry it out method because it can lead to quicker results compared to more gradual sleep training techniques. It helps babies learn to self-soothe, which is an essential skill for falling asleep independently. Additionally, once the initial adjustment period is over, both parents and babies often enjoy longer, uninterrupted sleep.
Why Some Parents Avoid Cry It Out
Despite its potential effectiveness, the cry it out method isn't for everyone. Some parents find it emotionally challenging to listen to their baby cry without intervening. Concerns about emotional development and the fear of causing stress or anxiety in their baby also deter some parents from using this method.
The cry it out method can be a polarizing topic among parents. It's essential to consider your family's needs, your baby's temperament, and your comfort level before deciding if it's the right approach for you. Remember, there's no one-size-fits-all solution to sleep training, and what works for one family might not work for another.
How the Cry It Out Method Works
The cry it out method, commonly known as CIO or the extinction method, is based on the principle that babies can learn to fall asleep on their own if given the opportunity. This approach involves putting your baby to bed awake and leaving the room, not returning until morning or in case of emergencies. Here’s a detailed look at how the cry it out method works, along with some personal anecdotes to illustrate the process.
Step-by-Step Process
Establish a Consistent Bedtime Routine Creating a calming bedtime routine is crucial. This might include a bath, feeding, storytime, and cuddles. The routine should signal to your baby that it’s time to wind down and prepare for sleep.
When we started CIO with my son, we made sure his bedtime routine was very consistent. Bath, book, and then bed. The predictability helped him understand that sleep time was coming.
Put Your Baby to Bed Awake After the routine, place your baby in their crib while they are still awake. This step is essential because it teaches them to associate their crib with falling asleep.
I remember the first night we put our daughter down awake. She looked at us with wide eyes, clearly confused about why she wasn’t being rocked to sleep.
Leave the Room Once your baby is in the crib, leave the room. If your baby starts crying, resist the urge to go back in. The aim is to allow your baby to self-soothe and learn to fall asleep independently. The only exceptions to re-entering the room should be for emergencies or for overnight feeding(s).
The first time we left the room, my son cried for what felt like hours, but was actually only about 30 minutes. It was incredibly tough not to rush back in immediately.
Do Not Return Until Morning The key to the cry it out method is consistency. With the exception of overnight feedings, do not go back into the room until the designated wake-up time in the morning. This reinforces the idea that night-time is for sleeping.
Why Cry It Out Can Be Effective
The cry it out method can be very effective because it teaches babies to self-soothe. When babies learn to fall asleep on their own, they are more likely to stay asleep through the night and return to sleep if they wake up. This method helps establish healthy sleep patterns and can significantly improve sleep for both the baby and the parents.
Concerns and Emotional Challenges
One of the primary concerns with the cry it out method is the emotional difficulty parents face when letting their baby cry. It can be heart-wrenching to hear your baby cry and not immediately comfort them. Some parents worry that it might cause stress or harm their baby’s emotional development. However, many child psychologists and pediatricians support this method, emphasizing that it does not harm emotional development.
I was initially very hesitant to try CIO because I couldn’t bear the thought of letting my baby cry without comforting him. However, after talking to our pediatrician and reading about the method, I felt more reassured.
The cry it out method is a tried-and-true sleep training technique for many families. While it requires a strong commitment and can be emotionally challenging, the potential benefits of teaching your baby to self-soothe and sleep independently can be well worth the effort. Always consider your baby's temperament and your family's comfort level before deciding if this method is right for you.
Effectiveness of the Cry It Out Method
The cry it out (CIO) method, often considered controversial, has proven effective for many families when it comes to sleep training. Here’s an in-depth look at its effectiveness, including personal anecdotes and insights from research.
Success Stories and Research
Many parents have reported significant improvements in their baby's sleep patterns using the cry it out method. These success stories are supported by research that shows CIO can lead to better sleep for both babies and their parents.
Improved Sleep Duration: Studies have shown that babies who undergo sleep training, including the CIO method, often sleep for longer periods at night. This not only helps the baby but also allows parents to get more restful sleep.
When we used the CIO method with our daughter, she went from waking up multiple times a night to sleeping through the night within a week. It was a game-changer for our family’s well-being.
Faster Sleep Onset: Babies who are trained with CIO typically learn to fall asleep faster. This is because they develop self-soothing skills, which are crucial for independent sleep.
After implementing CIO, we noticed that our son would fall asleep within minutes instead of taking an hour of rocking and nursing.
Positive Long-Term Effects: Research published in Pediatrics has indicated that sleep training, including CIO, does not have negative long-term effects on a child's emotional development or parent-child attachment. In fact, better sleep can contribute to overall well-being and development.
Initially, I was worried that CIO might affect my bond with my baby. But over time, I realized that well-rested nights made us all happier and more connected during the day.
The Emotional Challenge
While the cry it out method is effective, it can be emotionally challenging for parents. Hearing your baby cry and not responding immediately can be tough, but understanding that it is a temporary phase can help.
Parental Stress: It's natural for parents to feel stressed and guilty about letting their baby cry. However, knowing that this method is designed to teach self-soothing can provide some reassurance.
The first few nights were the hardest. I had to remind myself constantly that we were teaching our baby an important skill.
Baby’s Adjustment: Babies usually adjust to the CIO method within a few nights. Initially, there might be increased crying, but this typically decreases as the baby learns to fall asleep independently.
Our daughter cried for nearly an hour on the first night. By the third night, the crying reduced significantly, and she was able to sleep through the night.
Factors Affecting Effectiveness
The effectiveness of the cry it out method can vary based on several factors, including the baby’s temperament and the parents’ consistency.
Consistency: Being consistent with the CIO method is crucial. Inconsistency can confuse the baby and prolong the sleep training process.
We committed to being consistent, and it paid off. Skipping a night or giving in could have set us back.
Baby’s Temperament: Some babies may adapt to CIO more quickly than others. Parents need to consider their baby’s personality and adjust their approach if necessary.
Controversies Surrounding Cry It Out
The cry it out (CIO) method, despite its proven effectiveness, is often at the center of heated debates among parents, pediatricians, and child psychologists. Understanding these controversies can help parents make informed decisions about whether CIO is the right approach for their family.
Emotional and Psychological Concerns
One of the primary concerns about the cry it out method is the potential emotional and psychological impact on the baby. Critics argue that leaving a baby to cry without comfort can lead to feelings of abandonment and stress.
Attachment Issues: Some fear that CIO could damage the parent-child bond, creating a sense of insecurity and mistrust. However, studies, such as one published in Pediatrics, have shown that sleep training, including CIO, does not harm the emotional health or parent-child attachment in the long term.
Stress and Cortisol Levels: Another concern is the potential for elevated stress levels in babies, indicated by increased cortisol. Some studies have shown that while cortisol levels can rise during the initial nights of CIO, they typically normalize as the baby learns to self-soothe and sleep independently.
The first few nights of CIO were tough, and I could see my son was stressed. But as he adapted, he became calmer at bedtime, and his overall stress seemed to decrease.
Parental Stress and Guilt
The emotional toll on parents is another significant aspect of the controversy. Hearing their baby cry can be incredibly distressing, leading to feelings of guilt and second-guessing the decision to use CIO.
Emotional Toll on Parents: Many parents find the process emotionally taxing and may struggle with guilt, worrying they are causing their baby undue distress.
The first night we tried CIO, I sat outside my son’s room and cried along with him. It was one of the hardest things I’ve done as a parent. But seeing him sleep through the night after just a few days helped ease my worries.
Support Systems: Parents who choose CIO often benefit from having a supportive network, whether it’s a partner, family members, or a community of parents who have used similar methods. Sharing experiences and encouragement can help alleviate some of the emotional burden.
Cultural and Philosophical Differences
Different parenting philosophies and cultural backgrounds can influence opinions on sleep training methods like CIO. What is acceptable and effective in one culture might be frowned upon in another.
Cultural Perspectives: In some cultures, co-sleeping and immediate responsiveness to a baby's cries are the norms, making the CIO method seem harsh and unkind. Conversely, in cultures where independence is highly valued, CIO may be more readily accepted.
Parenting Styles: Attachment parenting advocates, for example, often oppose CIO, emphasizing constant closeness and responsiveness to a baby’s needs. On the other hand, proponents of more structured approaches to parenting may find CIO aligns well with their beliefs.
Balancing the Debate
Understanding the controversies and concerns surrounding the cry it out method is crucial for parents. It’s essential to weigh the potential benefits and challenges, considering the unique needs of their baby and family dynamics.
Personalized Approach: Every baby and family is different. What works for one may not work for another. It’s important to consider the baby’s temperament, parental comfort with the method, and overall family well-being when deciding on sleep training approaches.
We decided to give CIO a try after carefully considering our son’s needs and our family dynamics. It wasn’t an easy choice, but it ultimately worked well for us.
Seeking Professional Guidance: Consulting with pediatricians or baby sleep specialists can provide valuable insights and support, helping parents navigate the complexities of sleep training and address any concerns they may have.
Talking to our pediatrician helped us feel more confident about using CIO. Their reassurance and advice made a big difference in our experience.
Navigating the controversies of the cry it out method requires careful consideration and support. By understanding the different perspectives and focusing on the well-being of their baby and family, parents can make informed decisions about sleep training.
Comparing Cry It Out with Other Methods
When it comes to sleep training, the cry it out (CIO) method is just one of many approaches parents can consider. Each method has its own set of principles, benefits, and challenges. Here, we’ll compare CIO with other popular sleep training methods, helping you understand which might be the best fit for your family.
Cry It Out (CIO) Method
The CIO method, also known as the extinction method, involves putting your baby to bed while they are awake and then leaving them to fall asleep on their own, without any parental intervention. The key is consistency, and parents are encouraged not to return until morning unless there is an emergency.
Effectiveness: CIO is often effective within a few days to a week, teaching babies to self-soothe and fall asleep independently.
Challenges: Many parents find it emotionally challenging to hear their baby cry without intervening. It requires a strong commitment to the process and can be stressful for both baby and parents in the short term.
When we first tried CIO with our daughter, it was a tough few nights. The first evening was particularly hard as she cried for what felt like an eternity. By the third night, however, she was falling asleep on her own with minimal fussing. The quick results were reassuring and worth the initial emotional difficulty.
Ferber Method (Graduated Extinction)
The Ferber Method, developed by Dr. Richard Ferber, involves letting the baby cry for set intervals before briefly comforting them without picking them up. These intervals gradually increase over time.
Effectiveness: Similar to CIO, the Ferber Method can produce results within a week. It allows for periodic reassurance, which can be easier on parents emotionally.
Challenges: It still involves listening to your baby cry, which can be distressing. The process can take slightly longer than CIO due to the gradual approach.
My friend chose the Ferber Method for her son and found the progressive approach less stressful. She felt reassured by checking in on him, and he learned to self-soothe within a week.
Chair Method
The Chair Method involves a parent sitting in a chair next to the crib and gradually moving the chair further away each night until the baby can fall asleep independently without the parent in the room.
Effectiveness: The Chair Method can take longer, often a few weeks, but it allows for a more gradual separation, which can be comforting for both baby and parents.
Challenges: This method requires patience and consistency over a more extended period. It might be harder for parents to commit to sitting in the room for extended periods initially.
We tried the Chair Method with our son because we felt it might be gentler on him and on us. It was a slower process, but we appreciated the gradual transition. By the end of two weeks, he was sleeping through the night without us in the room.
Pick-Up/Put-Down Method
Popularized by Tracy Hogg, this method involves picking up the baby when they cry and putting them down once they are calm, repeating as necessary until the baby falls asleep.
Effectiveness: This method can work well for younger babies and those who need more physical reassurance. It teaches babies to fall asleep in their crib with the comfort of a parent nearby.
Challenges: It can be physically demanding and time-consuming for parents. Consistency and patience are crucial, and it might take several weeks to see results.
One of my clients used the Pick-Up/Put-Down Method with her newborn and found it to be a gentle way to transition her baby to self-soothing. It took about three weeks, but her baby eventually learned to fall asleep on his own.
No-Cry Sleep Solution
This method, advocated by Elizabeth Pantley, involves a gentle approach with minimal to no crying. It focuses on creating a consistent bedtime routine and slowly reducing sleep associations like rocking or feeding to sleep.
Effectiveness: The No-Cry Sleep Solution can be very effective, especially for parents who find crying methods distressing. It requires a significant time investment and patience.
Challenges: This method can take several months to see substantial changes, requiring a high level of commitment and consistency from parents.
A family I worked with preferred the No-Cry approach for their sensitive baby. They appreciated the gradual process and were willing to invest the time needed to see gentle progress over several months.
Balancing the Pros and Cons
Choosing a sleep training method often depends on the baby’s temperament, the parents' comfort levels, and the family’s overall needs. Each method has its own set of advantages and challenges, and what works for one family may not work for another.
Cry It Out: Best for parents who want quick results and can handle the initial emotional difficulty.
Ferber Method: Good for those who need to provide some intermittent comfort.
Chair Method: Suitable for parents who prefer a gradual transition.
Pick-Up/Put-Down: Ideal for younger babies needing more reassurance.
No-Cry Sleep Solution: Perfect for families who prefer a very gentle approach with minimal crying.
Understanding the various sleep training methods and their nuances can help you make an informed decision that best suits your family's needs. Whether you choose cry it out or another approach, the key is consistency and patience, and finding what works best for you and your baby.
Tips for Success with the Cry It Out Method
Implementing the cry it out (CIO) method can be challenging, but with the right approach and mindset, it can be an effective way to help your baby learn to self-soothe and sleep independently. Here are some tips to ensure success with the CIO method, drawn from both professional experience and personal anecdotes.
1. Establish a Consistent Bedtime Routine
Before starting the cry it out method, it’s crucial to establish a consistent and calming bedtime routine. This helps signal to your baby that it’s time to wind down and prepares them for sleep.
When we first started with CIO, we made sure to have a predictable bedtime routine for our daughter. This included a warm bath, a quiet story, and some gentle rocking. By the time we put her in her crib, she was relaxed and ready for sleep, which made the transition smoother.
2. Ensure Your Baby is Comfortable
Make sure your baby’s basic needs are met before bedtime. This includes feeding them, changing their diaper, and ensuring they are dressed comfortably for the night.
I always double-checked that my son was well-fed and had a fresh diaper before starting the night. Knowing he was physically comfortable helped me stay firm in not rushing back in at every cry.
3. Choose the Right Time to Start
Timing is essential when starting CIO. Make sure you begin during a period when there are no significant disruptions or changes in your baby’s life, such as teething, illness, or traveling.
We waited until our daughter was healthy and there were no major changes happening. Starting during a calm period in our lives made the process much less stressful.
4. Stay Consistent and Committed
Consistency is key with the cry it out method. Once you start, it’s important to stick to the plan and not give in to the temptation to check on your baby, as this can confuse them and prolong the process.
The first night was incredibly tough, and I almost gave in. But my husband and I reminded each other of our commitment. By the third night, the crying had significantly decreased, showing us that consistency was paying off.
5. Monitor from a Distance
While you shouldn’t go into the room, it’s okay to use a baby monitor to ensure your baby is safe. This can give you peace of mind and help you stay committed to the method.
Using a baby monitor helped me feel more at ease. I could hear that my son’s cries were more about frustration than anything else, which reassured me that he was okay.
6. Set a Time Limit
Decide in advance how long you are comfortable letting your baby cry before intervening, even if it’s just for an emergency. This helps manage your expectations and reduces the temptation to check too early.
We set a 30-minute limit initially, which we extended gradually. Knowing we had a plan helped us stay strong and not rush in prematurely.
7. Be Prepared for Setbacks
Expect that there will be some nights that are harder than others, especially during growth spurts or developmental milestones. Stay patient and don’t abandon the method if there’s a rough patch.
There were nights when my daughter would regress, especially during teething. We reminded ourselves that these setbacks were temporary and stayed consistent.
8. Support Each Other
If you have a partner, support each other through the process. It can be emotionally draining, and having someone to share the experience with can make it easier.
My husband and I took turns listening to the monitor and supporting each other. On tough nights, we reminded each other why we started and celebrated the small successes together.
9. Stay Calm and Positive
Your baby can sense your anxiety. Try to stay calm and positive, even when it’s challenging. Your confidence can help reassure your baby.
I practiced deep breathing and positive affirmations during the initial crying periods. Staying calm helped me handle the situation better and remain consistent.
10. Adjust as Needed
Every baby is different, and what works for one might not work for another. Be open to adjusting your approach if necessary, but stay consistent with the core principles of CIO.
We initially planned for longer check-ins but found that shorter intervals worked better for our son. We adjusted our approach while staying true to the method’s core.
The cry it out method requires patience, consistency, and emotional fortitude. By following these tips, you can help ensure a smoother process and ultimately, better sleep for both you and your baby. If you need further guidance, don't hesitate to reach out to a baby sleep consultant for personalized support.
When to Seek Professional Help
Navigating the cry it out (CIO) method can be a daunting experience, and it’s perfectly okay to seek professional help if you encounter difficulties or have concerns. Here are some scenarios where consulting a baby sleep expert or pediatrician might be beneficial.
Persistent Sleep Issues
If your baby continues to have sleep problems despite consistent efforts with the cry it out method, it might be time to seek professional advice. Persistent issues could indicate underlying conditions that need to be addressed.
When my daughter was still waking up multiple times a night after a few weeks of CIO, we decided to consult a pediatrician. It turned out she had mild reflux that was disrupting her sleep. Once we addressed that, her sleep improved significantly.
Extreme Distress
If your baby appears to be in extreme distress during the cry it out process, it’s important to listen to your instincts. While some crying is expected, excessive or unusual distress might warrant a closer look.
I remember one night when my son’s crying seemed different—more intense and continuous. I decided to call our pediatrician, who suggested a few adjustments to our approach and reassured us about his overall health.
Health Concerns
If your baby has health issues such as reflux, allergies, or other conditions that could affect their sleep, it’s crucial to work with a healthcare provider. They can offer tailored advice that takes your baby’s specific needs into account.
Our sleep consultant helped us adjust our CIO approach by suggesting we elevate one side of the crib mattress slightly, which helped with our daughter’s reflux and improved her sleep.
Parental Stress
The emotional toll of implementing the cry it out method can be significant. If you find that the process is causing substantial stress or anxiety for you or your partner, seeking professional guidance can provide much-needed support and reassurance.
There were nights when the crying was just too much for me to handle emotionally. Talking to a baby sleep expert helped me understand the process better and gave me strategies to cope with the stress.
Consistency Challenges
If you’re struggling to stay consistent with the CIO method, a sleep consultant can offer strategies to help maintain consistency, which is key to the method’s success.
Consistency was a big challenge for us, especially with our unpredictable schedules. Our sleep consultant helped us develop a more flexible yet consistent routine that fit our lifestyle better.
Lack of Progress
If there’s no noticeable improvement in your baby’s sleep after a reasonable period of using the cry it out method, professional help can provide new insights and strategies that you might not have considered.
Seeking professional help doesn’t mean you’ve failed; it’s a proactive step to ensure your baby’s sleep health and your family’s well-being. Sleep consultants and pediatricians can provide personalized advice and support, making the sleep training journey less overwhelming.
If you’re facing challenges with the cry it out method or have concerns about your baby’s sleep, don’t hesitate to reach out to a professional. Their expertise can make a world of difference in achieving restful nights for both you and your baby.
Navigating the world of baby sleep training can be challenging, and the cry it out (CIO) method is no exception. While this approach has its share of controversies, it has also proven effective for many families. Understanding the CIO method, how it works, and the reasons behind its effectiveness can help you make an informed decision about whether it’s right for your family.
The cry it out method is straightforward in concept but can be emotionally taxing in practice. It requires patience, consistency, and a strong commitment to seeing it through. As with any sleep training method, it's crucial to consider your baby’s temperament, health, and your family dynamics.
It’s important to remember that every baby is different, and what works for one might not work for another. If you find yourself struggling with the cry it out method, don’t hesitate to seek professional help. Sleep consultants and pediatricians can offer tailored advice and support, making the process more manageable.
Whether you choose CIO or another sleep training method, the ultimate goal is to help your baby develop healthy sleep habits. Consistency, patience, and a supportive approach will go a long way in achieving restful nights for both you and your little one.
And if you’re curious about other sleep training methods or need more tips along the way, be sure to check out the rest of our Sleep Training Series. You’ve got this, and I’m here to help every step of the way!
Learn more-
Feeling overwhelmed with your baby's sleep challenges? You're not alone! At Dreaming Littles, we're dedicated to helping you and your baby achieve peaceful nights and joyful mornings. Reach out to us for personalized guidance, support, and expert strategies tailored to your family's needs. Let's make those sleepless nights a thing of the past! Book your FREE consultation today!